NEW DELHI: Citing that the passenger had taken "reasonable precautions" to safeguard his luggage but the TTE failed in his responsibility to prevent entry of "outsiders" in the reserved coach, NCDRC has ordered Railways to pay nearly Rs 4.7 lakh compensation to the traveller whose belongings were stolen. The incident happened on Amarkantak Express in May 2017.
Passing the order Monday, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) dismissed Railways' argument that under Section 100 of Railway Act its administration is not responsible for loss, destruction or deterioration unless a railway man has booked the luggage and given a receipt. Imposing a cost of Rs 20,000 on Railways for causing mental agony to the passenger, an NCDRC bench comprising Justice Sudip Ahluwalia and Rohit Kumar Singh, said, "...it is concluded that Railways is liable for the theft, and there was deficiency in service provided to the petitioner (passenger) owing to negligence of railway officials concerned." The Railways owe a duty of care towards passengers travelling in a reserved coach with their personal belongings and luggage, it said.
NCDRC passed the order while hearing a revision petition filed by Durg-based Dilip Kumar Chaturvedi against the order of Chhattisgarh State Consumer Commission.
The case dates back to May 9, 2017, when Chaturvedi with his family was travelling from Katni to Durg in a sleeper coach. He had lodged an FIR with railway police about his luggage - cash and articles of around Rs 9.3 lakh in value - being stolen around 2.30am. He then filed a case in the Durg district consumer commission, which directed South East Central Railway GM, Durg station master, and Bilaspur GRP thana in-charge to pay the claimed amount. But, the respondents challenged the order in the state commission, which quashed the district commission's order.
Chaturvedi filed a revision petition before NCDRC, submitting that the TTE and railway police staff were grossly negligent in allowing "unauthorised persons" in the reserved coach. His counsel submitted that the stolen luggage was duly chained and the defence of section 100 cannot be extended in case of negligence.
Passing the order Monday, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) dismissed Railways' argument that under Section 100 of Railway Act its administration is not responsible for loss, destruction or deterioration unless a railway man has booked the luggage and given a receipt. Imposing a cost of Rs 20,000 on Railways for causing mental agony to the passenger, an NCDRC bench comprising Justice Sudip Ahluwalia and Rohit Kumar Singh, said, "...it is concluded that Railways is liable for the theft, and there was deficiency in service provided to the petitioner (passenger) owing to negligence of railway officials concerned." The Railways owe a duty of care towards passengers travelling in a reserved coach with their personal belongings and luggage, it said.
NCDRC passed the order while hearing a revision petition filed by Durg-based Dilip Kumar Chaturvedi against the order of Chhattisgarh State Consumer Commission.
The case dates back to May 9, 2017, when Chaturvedi with his family was travelling from Katni to Durg in a sleeper coach. He had lodged an FIR with railway police about his luggage - cash and articles of around Rs 9.3 lakh in value - being stolen around 2.30am. He then filed a case in the Durg district consumer commission, which directed South East Central Railway GM, Durg station master, and Bilaspur GRP thana in-charge to pay the claimed amount. But, the respondents challenged the order in the state commission, which quashed the district commission's order.
Chaturvedi filed a revision petition before NCDRC, submitting that the TTE and railway police staff were grossly negligent in allowing "unauthorised persons" in the reserved coach. His counsel submitted that the stolen luggage was duly chained and the defence of section 100 cannot be extended in case of negligence.
You may also like
Uttarakhand moves to stop 'spitting' in food, issues norms for eateries
Liam Payne dead: Celebrities pay tribute to One Direction star who died aged 31 in Argentina
Congress may pledge Karnataka-like '5 guarantees' in Maharashtra
Liam Payne and Cheryl's heartbreak behind fresh start for son Bear before star's tragic death
Liam Payne's haunting 'last' picture taken minutes before plummeting to death
Maharashtra polls: BJP discusses candidates at Central Election Committee meet, list likely to be announced within a week
KSI joins Britain's Got Talent judges on red carpet for new season's auditions
Daily Horoscope for Thursday, October 17, 2024, for all zodiac signs by astrologer Vinayak Vishwas Karandikar
How To Clean a Sofa at Home Without a Vacuum Cleaner
"Black Alien" pierces amputated nose hole in latest grisly body modification
Pep Guardiola jokingly accused on ruining soccer by World Cup winner
Assisted dying is a hugely controversial subject and we deserve to hear both sides
Shah Rukh Khan Quips 'Not Stereotyped, I'm Hero Type', Wishes To Play Assassin: I've A New Way Of Playing A Bad Guy
Maharashtra nixes tender, 100 GRs issued after poll announced
London sides with Ottawa in diplomatic row with India
Grand Designs couple's project halted after hospital dash in devastating blow
Woman of the Hour is a star-making turn for one actress who even outshines Anna Kendrick
Rio Ferdinand at odds with Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher on Thomas Tuchel appointment
South African Police detain suspects for mass shooting
Inside Linda Hunt's life from a tough childhood to NCIS LA fame and lifelong romance